In an unexpected twist of storytelling, Marty Supreme took a wild turn that left even its producers at A24 surprised. The film, directed by Josh Safdie and starring Timothée Chalamet, initially featured a shocking original ending where vampirism played a central role. In an interview with Sean Baker on the A24 Podcast, Safdie divulged how the surprising finale left audiences and studio executives questioning its intent, asking, “This is a mistake, right?”
### The Scrapped Vampiric Ending
Josh Safdie shared that in an early draft of Marty Supreme, Chalamet’s character, a ping-pong prodigy who rose to become a successful businessman, faced an unexpected destiny. Initially, the story arc took him to the late ’80s, thriving as a business owner of a shoe franchise and contemplating life’s deeper meanings at a Tears for Fears concert. The narrative, however, took a vampiric turn when Milton Rockwell, portrayed by Kevin O’Leary, unexpectedly bites him, alluding to Rockwell’s earlier line, “I’m a vampire.”
### Behind the Surprising Scene
“He turns that [shoe store] into the most successful shop on Orchard Street,” Safdie explained, describing the envisioned success and eventual transformation of Chalamet’s role. “Franchises, franchises again, leaves New York State, becomes a very rich man… but he’s not doing the thing that he believed he was born on the planet to do.” Then, in an astonishing twist, “Mr. Wonderful shows up behind him and takes a bite out of his neck,” marking the film’s finale with the supernatural element.
### A24’s Reaction and O’Leary’s Input
The unexpected turn caught A24 by surprise. Safdie recalled that the studio’s execs, upon reviewing this conclusion, questioned, “This is a mistake, right?” Kevin O’Leary, intrigued by the outcome and drama, was enthusiastic about this narrative direction. He shared with Variety that Safdie “went as far as to make digital teeth,” expressing his support for the original concept, which he viewed as the “right punishment” for Chalamet’s character.
### Exploring Alternative Endings
The film’s initial conclusion left O’Leary feeling unsatisfied with its lack of justice for his character, who felt wronged by Marty’s prosperous end. He suggested a more tragic conclusion where Odessa A’Zion’s character, Rachel, suffers dramatically, adding a layer of poetic justice to Marty Mauser’s storyline. Safdie considered this intense suggestion but found it excessively “sick” for the final cut.
In the end, Marty Supreme opted for a more conventional conclusion, leaving the intriguing vampiric storyline a fascinating footnote in cinematic history.






