Martin Short and Selena Gomez made an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live to promote the upcoming season of their hit series Only Murders in the Building, which will be set in London. However, before diving into the details of the new episodes, host Jimmy Kimmel prompted Short to revisit a humorous story he shared back in January—one that nearly derailed Gomez’s wedding to Benny Blanco.
Short Recounts the Cake Incident
Kimmel encouraged Short to give a brief overview of the cake-related debacle. “First of all, it’s insane because I am blameless in the story,” Short stated, attempting to clarify his position. He recounted the extravagant wedding, noting, “Selena had the most fabulous, beautiful wedding imaginable. In one major tent where the after-ceremony took place, there were 18 to 20 musicians and a dance floor—it resembled a nightclub.”
Short described the setup, complete with sofas for guests, and then revealed the moment he made a grave misunderstanding regarding the wedding cake. “There was this cake there, and I just assumed it was a cake for each individual group,” he explained. Unfortunately for all involved, it turned out to be the wedding cake. Short, admitting to “maybe” having had a drink, couldn’t resist and cut into the cake with a fork just as Steve Martin was leaving the festivities. Kimmel then showcased a photo of the now-infamous damaged cake.
Gomez’s Perspective
“I love the teeth marks of the fork where he tried to save it,” Gomez joked, admiring the remnants of the cake. She added that Short “apparently insisted” no one tell her about the incident. “They managed to put it together,” she recalled. “And I didn’t care. I was there, but I didn’t know what happened. Suddenly, somebody comes up and says, ‘Marty cut your cake. And I think he was eating it.’ I was like, ‘Oh!’ So I ran over, and he looked like a little dog with his tail between his legs. I said, ‘I heard you ate my cake.’”
Gomez further explained that the cake was meant to be a personal moment for her and Blanco, but it unintentionally became a shared experience with Short. “We will always have that memory together, and honestly, I will never forget it,” she concluded, reflecting fondly on the mishap.
Wedding Details and Upcoming Season
Gomez and Blanco tied the knot last September in a ceremony attended by numerous celebrities, including Taylor Swift, who delivered a memorable speech. Alongside Short and Martin, several cast members from Only Murders in the Building were also present. After the cake incident, Short humorously turned to Paul Rudd and asked, “Should we just leave?”
Fans of the duo can catch the new season of Only Murders in the Building, which premieres on December 8 on Hulu.





